Jump to content

Hash Functions in Gambling

From Crypto Gambling Wiki
Revision as of 03:19, 15 February 2025 by Loquc (talk | contribs) (Created page with "= Hash Functions in Gambling = == Introduction == '''Hash functions''' play a pivotal role in modern '''provably fair gambling''', ensuring that neither the casino nor the player can secretly manipulate game outcomes. By leveraging the cryptographic properties of hash algorithms such as SHA-256 and Keccak-256, online gambling platforms demonstrate transparent and verifiable randomness. This article explores the technical foundations of cryptographic hash functions, thei...")
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

Hash Functions in Gambling

Introduction

Hash functions play a pivotal role in modern provably fair gambling, ensuring that neither the casino nor the player can secretly manipulate game outcomes. By leveraging the cryptographic properties of hash algorithms such as SHA-256 and Keccak-256, online gambling platforms demonstrate transparent and verifiable randomness. This article explores the technical foundations of cryptographic hash functions, their integration into provably fair protocols, notable real-world implementations, common security pitfalls, and the broader regulatory and ethical landscape.

Technical Foundations of Cryptographic Hash Functions

Cryptographic Hash Functions

A cryptographic hash function is an algorithm that takes an input of arbitrary length and deterministically produces a fixed-length output known as a digest or hash. A key characteristic is the “avalanche effect”: a small change in the input causes a drastic change in the output.[1] Hash functions such as SHA-256 and Keccak-256 generate outputs of 256 bits but rely on different internal designs (e.g., Keccak’s sponge construction). These functions are designed to be one-way: given a hash output, it is computationally infeasible to recover the original input.[2]

Key Security Properties

Modern hash algorithms exhibit three critical security properties:[3][4]

  1. Pre-image resistance: It is infeasible to find an input that produces a given hash.
  2. Second pre-image resistance: Given one input, finding a different input that hashes to the same output is infeasible.
  3. Collision resistance: Finding any two distinct inputs that produce the same hash is extremely unlikely.

These properties guarantee that once a casino publishes a hash of a secret seed, neither players nor the casino itself can feasibly alter the committed value or guess it in advance.

Hash Functions as RNGs

Cryptographic hashes behave like pseudo-random functions when the input seed is unknown. The outputs are effectively random and uniformly distributed, making them suitable for deriving random game outcomes in a verifiable manner. Determinism ensures that the same inputs will always produce the same hash, enabling precise verification once the secret input is revealed.[5]

Common Algorithms (SHA-256, Keccak, etc.)

In crypto gambling, the most commonly used hash function is SHA-256. It is well-vetted and widely recognized due to its use in Bitcoin.[6] Keccak-256 (standardized as SHA-3) is also employed, particularly in blockchain-based casinos. Casinos typically avoid weakened algorithms like MD5 or SHA-1 because collisions have been demonstrated for those older hashes.[7]

How Hash Functions Enable Provably Fair Gambling

Commitment and Reveal (Seeds and Hashes)

Provably fair systems often use a commit–reveal protocol. The casino generates a secret server seed before a bet and shares only its hash with the player, thus committing to that seed without revealing it.[8][9] Players either provide or receive a client seed, which is known to both sides. A nonce (an incrementing counter) differentiates each round so that subsequent bets produce new outputs.[10][11] The casino then combines the server seed, client seed, and nonce through a cryptographic hash or HMAC, generating the random result in a way that is unpredictable before reveal but perfectly reproducible after.

Client-Side Verification

Once the round concludes, the casino discloses the original server seed. Because the player already has the client seed and nonce, they can re-hash these inputs to confirm that the outcome aligns with the casino’s commitment.[12] If the revealed server seed does not match the previously disclosed hash, tampering would be evident.

Seeds, Nonces, and Combining Inputs

By incorporating both a server seed (unknown to the player) and a client seed (unknown to the casino), the game outcome cannot be fully controlled by any single party. A nonce ensures each bet is unique without having to constantly replace seeds.[13] Some casinos start the nonce at 1 or skip 0 due to minor technical debates about potential manipulation, but the principle remains the same.[14]

Outcome Derivation and Transparency

After producing a hash from server seed, client seed, and nonce, casinos convert that hash into a specific game result (e.g., a dice roll or card draw). Algorithms that map the large hash output to a smaller outcome space must avoid bias, often by discarding results outside a valid range and re-sampling if needed.[15] Casinos publish details on how these computations work, and third-party scripts or tools can be used by players to verify results independently.

Provably Fair in Action: Case Studies

Stake.com / Primedice

Primedice (and later its successor Stake.com) built one of the earliest widely scrutinized provably fair dice systems. The casino generates a secret server seed, which is hashed with the client seed and an incrementing nonce via HMAC-SHA512.[16] The HMAC output is parsed in 5-character segments to yield a fair roll between 0.00 and 99.99 without bias.[17]

Crash Games on Stake.com use a 32-bit random draw from the combined hash to determine the “crash” multiplier. A formula such as multiplier = ⌊(2^32 / (X + 1)) * (1 - house_edge)⌋ is applied, where X is a 32-bit integer derived from the hash.[18][19] Players can verify each crash outcome by re-computing the hash with the revealed server seed.

BC.Game

BC.Game implements several sophisticated approaches:

  • Crash Game with Hash Chains: The platform pre-generates a long chain of hashes via SHA-256, where each hash is the digest of the next. Each hash commits to a future round’s outcome. Since hashing is one-way, the casino cannot retroactively alter later results without invalidating the chain.[20][21]
  • Card Shuffling (e.g., Blackjack): BC.Game uses a combination of hashing and digital signatures. A shuffle seed is signed with RSA, and the public key is released for verification. The deck is then shuffled deterministically based on a SHA-256 process applied to the seed.[22][23] This design ensures the casino cannot alter the deal without breaking the signature verification.
  • HashDice: BC.Game’s HashDice game also uses SHA-256 in a typical commit–reveal or HMAC framework, mapping a combined hash to a dice roll.[24]

Roobet

Roobet’s Crash and other games (Mines, Roulette) follow a standard commit–reveal scheme. The casino commits to a server seed by publishing its hash and uses a client seed or round nonce to produce the final hashed outcome.[25][26] After each round, the casino reveals the server seed so that players can re-compute and confirm the crash point or other outcomes. While the house edge may vary, the principle remains the same: neither party can cheat without detection by mismatching the disclosed hash.[27][28]

Security and Known Exploits in Provably Fair Systems

Although the cryptographic core of provably fair systems is robust, several real-world implementation pitfalls have occurred:

  • Predictable Client Seeds: A dishonest operator might manipulate or anticipate a player’s seed if it is weak or repeated, though standard procedures require the casino to commit to its seed first.[29]
  • Static Nonce or Poor Implementation: Sites that do not incorporate any user-supplied randomness or rely on a fixed client seed can allow the house to know all future outcomes.[30]
  • Stacked Initial State: Known as the “Shufflepuff” exploit, a casino might claim to shuffle a deck fairly using a hash-based RNG but secretly begin with a biased arrangement. This preserves the appearance of randomness yet tilts odds against players. Full transparency about initial ordering or additional verifications can mitigate this.[31]
  • Hash Function Weaknesses: No practical collisions or pre-image attacks exist for SHA-256 or Keccak. Casinos using older algorithms such as MD5 or SHA-1 risk feasible collisions, which would undermine fairness.[32]
  • Nonce Overflow & Implementation Bugs: Failure to reset seeds before a 32-bit nonce wraps around could allow repeated outcomes after 2^32 bets.[33] Additionally, concurrency issues can cause seeds to be reused inadvertently, as happened in a prominent Primedice exploit.

Regulatory and Ethical Considerations

Licensing and Legal Frameworks

Provably fair gambling primarily arose from relatively unregulated crypto casinos. While it does not replace a gambling license, it serves as a transparent self-regulatory mechanism. Some regulated jurisdictions are exploring or permitting provably fair features as an enhancement to traditional audits.[34] Players should note that provably fair verification does not guarantee other forms of consumer protection or solvency of the operator.

Fairness and Transparency

Provably fair technology helps build trust by letting players independently verify each result. Many casinos provide open-source or third-party tools to facilitate verification, although not all players will engage in detailed checks. The mere possibility of verification often deters cheating, given the threat of immediate reputation damage if tampering is detected.[35]

Potential Misuse

Subtle biases (like starting from a rigged deck or embedding hidden parameters) remain possible if the system’s entire process is not transparent. Community vigilance plays a key role in detecting anomalies, as suspicious patterns in game outcomes can prompt investigation and expose malpractice.

Impact on the Industry

Provably fair systems have influenced even mainstream online casinos to adopt more transparent practices. Some hybrid models now incorporate provable fairness in licensed environments, and it may become more commonplace as regulators become familiar with blockchain-based and cryptographic auditing tools. Several game providers (e.g., BGaming) integrate provable fairness directly into their slot or table game solutions.[36]

References

  1. ↑ Understanding Provable Fairness: Seeds, Hashes, HMAC and mathMAX (https://crashgambler.io/understanding-provable-fairness-in-crash-games/#:~:text=Hashing%20functions%20are%20essentially%20tools,always%20generates%20the%20same%20output)
  2. ↑ How are hash functions used to make gambling sites fair? : r/learnprogramming (https://www.reddit.com/r/learnprogramming/comments/of6x2i/how_are_hash_functions_used_to_make_gambling/#:~:text=Hash%20functions%20are%20not%20reversible,input%20produced%20a%20certain%20output)
  3. ↑ Preimage Resistance, Second Preimage Resistance, & Collision Resistance (https://freemanlaw.com/preimage-resistance-second-preimage-resistance-and-collision-resistance/#:~:text=Preimage%20resistance%20is%20one%20component,input%20that%20matches%20such%20element)
  4. ↑ How are hash functions used to make gambling sites fair? : r/learnprogramming (https://www.reddit.com/r/learnprogramming/comments/of6x2i/how_are_hash_functions_used_to_make_gambling/#:~:text=It%27s%20essentially%20impossible%20for%20the,Hashes)
  5. ↑ Understanding Provable Fairness: Seeds, Hashes, HMAC and mathMAX (https://crashgambler.io/understanding-provable-fairness-in-crash-games/#:~:text=Hashing%20functions%20are%20essentially%20tools,always%20generates%20the%20same%20output)
  6. ↑ Preimage Resistance, Second Preimage Resistance, & Collision Resistance (https://freemanlaw.com/preimage-resistance-second-preimage-resistance-and-collision-resistance/#:~:text=Collision%20resistance%20is%20also%20a,%E2%80%9D)
  7. ↑ Preimage Resistance, Second Preimage Resistance, & Collision Resistance (https://freemanlaw.com/preimage-resistance-second-preimage-resistance-and-collision-resistance/#:~:text=Collision%20resistance%20is%20also%20a,%E2%80%9D)
  8. ↑ Provably Fair Gambling Explained With Details & Examples (https://gamingtec.com/news/provably-fair-explained#:~:text=At%20the%20start%20of%20each,and%20giving%20you%20the%20envelope)
  9. ↑ Provably Fair Gambling Explained With Details & Examples (https://gamingtec.com/news/provably-fair-explained#:~:text=After%20the%20game%2C%20the%20server,know%20the%20game%20was%20fair)
  10. ↑ Provably Fair Gambling Explained With Details & Examples (https://gamingtec.com/news/provably-fair-explained#:~:text=1,each%20game%20round%20is%20unique)
  11. ↑ Provably Fair Gambling Explained With Details & Examples (https://gamingtec.com/news/provably-fair-explained#:~:text=2,each%20game%20round%20is%20unique)
  12. ↑ Understanding Provable Fairness: Seeds, Hashes, HMAC and mathMAX (https://crashgambler.io/understanding-provable-fairness-in-crash-games/#:~:text=If%20the%20hash%20you%20received,was%20indeed%20random%20and%20fair)
  13. ↑ Provably Fair Gambling Explained With Details & Examples (https://gamingtec.com/news/provably-fair-explained#:~:text=2,each%20game%20round%20is%20unique)
  14. ↑ algorithm design - How do bad actors manipulate game results in real time within 'provably fair' gaming systems? - Cryptography Stack Exchange (https://crypto.stackexchange.com/questions/108923/how-do-bad-actors-manipulate-game-results-in-real-time-within-provably-fair-ga#:~:text=to%20the%20client%20in%20hashed,system%20from%20being%20%27provably%20fair)
  15. ↑ Implementation of the Primedice provably fair algorithm (https://dicesites.com/primedice/verifier) · GitHub (https://gist.github.com/4Kaylum/6bbb3dcd9ebb0545ba8e692391d5fedd#:~:text=while%20True%3A%20number_str%20%3D%20full_number,counter%20%2B%3D%205%20else%3A%20break)
  16. ↑ Implementation of the Primedice provably fair algorithm (https://dicesites.com/primedice/verifier) · GitHub (https://gist.github.com/4Kaylum/6bbb3dcd9ebb0545ba8e692391d5fedd#:~:text=%2Csha512)
  17. ↑ Implementation of the Primedice provably fair algorithm (https://dicesites.com/primedice/verifier) · GitHub (https://gist.github.com/4Kaylum/6bbb3dcd9ebb0545ba8e692391d5fedd#:~:text=while%20True%3A%20number_str%20%3D%20full_number,counter%20%2B%3D%205%20else%3A%20break)
  18. ↑ Understanding Provable Fairness: Seeds, Hashes, HMAC and mathMAX (https://crashgambler.io/understanding-provable-fairness-in-crash-games/#:~:text=hexadecimal%20digits,converting%20the%20game%E2%80%99s%20combined%20hash)
  19. ↑ Understanding Provable Fairness: Seeds, Hashes, HMAC and mathMAX (https://crashgambler.io/understanding-provable-fairness-in-crash-games/#:~:text=,adjust%20for%20the%20house%20edge)
  20. ↑ How are hash functions used to make gambling sites fair? : r/learnprogramming (https://www.reddit.com/r/learnprogramming/comments/of6x2i/how_are_hash_functions_used_to_make_gambling/#:~:text=What%20they%20did%20was%20generate,but%20that%27s%20a%20minor%20detail)
  21. ↑ Provably fair | BC White Paper (https://whitepaper.bc.game/bc-white-paper/appendix/provably-fair#:~:text=Conclusion%3A%20The%20hash%20value%20used,in%20which%20crash%20is%20a)
  22. ↑ Provably fair | BC White Paper (https://whitepaper.bc.game/bc-white-paper/appendix/provably-fair#:~:text=Example%3A%206b5124897c3c48d0e46cc9249f08c7e560792459f1bad1171224643b5d2be231%20Take%20a%20random,1887939992208324%20in%20the%20decimal%20system)
  23. ↑ Provably fair | BC White Paper (https://whitepaper.bc.game/bc-white-paper/appendix/provably-fair#:~:text=Make%20the%20house%20edge%201,result%20is%20less%20than%20100)
  24. ↑ How to Play Hash Dice? - Bc Game Help Center (https://help.bc.game/en/articles/7831406-how-to-play-hash-dice#:~:text=How%20to%20Play%20Hash%20Dice%3F,Client%20Seed%20is%20used)
  25. ↑ Crash by Roobet │ Is It Worth The Hype? Well, Kinda. (https://crashgambler.io/crash-by-roobet/#:~:text=,calls%20it%2C%20of%20the%20game)
  26. ↑ Crash by Roobet │ Is It Worth The Hype? Well, Kinda. (https://crashgambler.io/crash-by-roobet/#:~:text=To%20access%20the%20information%20about,bottom%20of%20the%20game%E2%80%99s%20interface)
  27. ↑ Crash by Roobet │ Is It Worth The Hype? Well, Kinda. (https://crashgambler.io/crash-by-roobet/#:~:text=In%20order%20to%20verify%20the,clicking%20on%20the%20game%E2%80%99s%20result)
  28. ↑ Crash by Roobet │ Is It Worth The Hype? Well, Kinda. (https://crashgambler.io/crash-by-roobet/#:~:text=In%20fact%2C%20two%20of%20our,of%20Roobet%20crash%20game%20alternatives)
  29. ↑ Provably fair = Stake is able to anticipate the client seed - Casino Discussion - Stake Forum (https://stakecommunity.com/topic/47231-provably-fair-stake-is-able-to-anticipate-the-client-seed/#:~:text=perspective%2C%20this%20does%20not%20change,result%20in%20the%20house%27s%20favor)
  30. ↑ What is a "provably fair" gambling system, how are sites able know futures outcomes and why certain skin gambling sites are by definition NOT fair : r/pcmasterrace (https://www.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/4rdiqe/what_is_a_provably_fair_gambling_system_how_are/#:~:text=CS%3AGO%20Diamonds%20pick%20their%20own,knows%20each%20others%20random%20numbers)
  31. ↑ Provably Fair Can Cheat Players. Proof and code provided. - Casino Discussion - Stake Forum (https://stakecommunity.com/topic/58374-provably-fair-can-cheat-players-proof-and-code-provided/#:~:text=The%20exploit%20that%20casinos%20can,code%20provided%20below%20in%20picture)
  32. ↑ Preimage Resistance, Second Preimage Resistance, & Collision Resistance (https://freemanlaw.com/preimage-resistance-second-preimage-resistance-and-collision-resistance/#:~:text=Collision%20resistance%20is%20also%20a,%E2%80%9D)
  33. ↑ Dices provably fair - Nonce overflow vulnerability - Davide Gessa @dakk (https://dakk.github.io/bitcoin/2015/02/26/dice_nonce_overflow.html#:~:text=But%2C%20what%20if%20this%20nonce,overflow%20and%20return%20to%200)
  34. ↑ Understanding ‘Provably Fair’ in iGaming - Gofaizen & Sherle (https://gofaizen-sherle.com/blog/understanding-provably-fair-in-igaming#:~:text=Provably%20Fair%20,any%20changes%20during%20the%20game)
  35. ↑ Provably Fair Games at Crypto Casinos – How Do They Work? (https://lowerbuckstimes.com/what-is-provably-fair-technology/#:~:text=There%20are%20two%20vital%20functions,of%20hashing)
  36. ↑ Understanding ‘Provably Fair’ in iGaming - Gofaizen & Sherle (https://gofaizen-sherle.com/blog/understanding-provably-fair-in-igaming#:~:text=This%20suggests%20that%20games%20using,2020)
Retrieved from "https://cryptogamblingwiki.org/index.php?title=Hash_Functions_in_Gambling&oldid=24"